Majority
p. 932The People of the State of New York ex rel. Peter Fitzgerald, Respondent, v. Charles D. Collins, Appellant.
Judgment of the County Court and judgment of Court of Special Sessions reversed. Held, that the failure of the justice to keep any minutes of the testimony renders it impossible to determine that part of defendant’s appeal which alleges that his conviction is unsupported by evidence. (People v. Giles, 12 App. Div. 495 ; 152 N. Y. 136 ; People ex rel. Commissioner v. Benson, 63 App. Div. 142 ; People v. Hines, 57 id. 419.) All concurred.
Cases cited
- People v. Giles 152 N. Y. 136 p. 932
- People ex rel. Commissioners of Public Charities v. Benson 63 App. Div. 142 p. 932