← Cases

McManus v. Buffalo Taxicab Co.

176 A.D. 897 Court N.Y. App. Div. English

Contents

Majority

p. 897
Nellie McManus, Respondent, v. Buffalo Taxicab Company, Appellant.

Judgment and order affirmed, with costs. Held: 1. That the

conduct of the trial court was such that a reversal thereon would be required, if the record upon this appeal permitted the conclusion that such attitude and conduct had affected the result, but that such a conclusion is not warranted by the merits of the action. 2. The evidence introduced upon the part of the defendant is substantially a confession of negligence by the defendant. The plaintiff is clearly free from the charge of contribution to the injury. Under these circumstances a new trial should be denied. All concurred.