Majority
p. 867Kate Deane Andrew, as Executrix, etc., of Esther B. Steele, Deceased, Respondent, v. American Book Company, Appellant.
Judgment reversed and complaint dismissed, with costs, on the ground that under the statute[1] the plaintiff could not renew the copyrights. All concur; Kiley, J., on the further ground that the action -is not maintainable under section 19 of the Personal Property Law.
* See Federal Copyright Act of 1909 (35U. S. Stat. at Large, 1080), § § 23, 24.— [Rep.