Dissent
(dissenting). We dissent and vote to reverse the decree appealed from so as to construe subdivision “ c ” of paragraph “ Fourteenth ” of the will of Jennie Orr, deceased, as giving the remainder of the trust therein created to the issue of the lifetime income beneficiary, Robert M. Dunham, such gift to take effect as of the date of the death of the testator, not to be subject to being divested by the death of such issue prior to the death of Robert M. Dunham; and sustaining the right of appellants to receive the remainder under their assignments from Donald O. Dunham (Matter of McParlan, 169 Misc. 1028 ; Matter of Embree, 9 App. Div. 602 , affd. 154 N. Y. 778 ; Doe ex dem. Barnes v. Provoost, 4 Johns. 61 ; Moore v. Lyons, 25 Wend. 119 , 144; Livingston v. Greene, 52 N. Y. 118 , 123; Nelson v. Russell, 135 N. Y. 137 , 140-141; Connelly v. O’Brien, 166 N. Y. 406 , 408; Matter of Bump, 234 N. Y. 60 , 65; Matter of Watson, 262 N. Y. 284 ; 7 Heaton on Surrogates’ Courts, §§ 571, 572; 69 C. J., Wills, § 1730, p. 641).
Peck, P. J., Glennon and Shientag, JJ., concur in decision; Callahan and Yan Yoorhis, JJ., dissent in opinion.
Decree affirmed, with costs. No opinion. [ 192 Misc. 608 .]
Cases cited
- In re Morris' Estate 9 App. Div. 602 p. 702
- Bodine v. Brown 154 N. Y. 778 p. 702
- Doe ex dem. Barnes v. Provoost 4 Johns. 61 p. 702
- Livingston v. Greene 52 N. Y. 118 at 123 p. 702
- Nelson v. Russell 135 N. Y. 137 at 140-141 p. 702
- Connelly v. O'Brien 166 N. Y. 406 at 408 p. 702
- In re the Will of Bump 234 N. Y. 60 at 65 p. 702
- In re the Accounting of the United States Trust Co. 262 N. Y. 284 p. 702
- In re the Construction of the Will of Orr 192 Misc. 608 p. 702