Majority
The finding of the jury is against the weight of the evidence. Nolan, P. J., Adel and Wenzel, JJ., concur; Carswell, J., dissents and votes to affirm on the following cases: Costello v. Forest Hills Dwellings ( 227 App. Div. 736 ); Cantone v. City of New York ( 273 App. Div. 864 ); Russo v. Sorrentino ( 250 App. Div. 882 , smooth ice condition); Fitzgerald v. City of New Rochelle ( 259 App. Div. 1015 , motion for leave to appeal denied 285 N. Y. 856 , smooth ice condition); Williams v. City of New York ( 214 N. Y. 259 , 263); Bordonaro v. Bank of Blasdell ( 285 N. Y. 606 ); Berkowitz v. Prudential Sav. Bank ( 269 App. Div. 988 ); Ringel v. Jaffe ( 254 App. Div. 892 ); Galvano v. Klein, Inc. ( 257 App. Div. 989 ); Galvano v. City of New York ( 260 App. Div. 926 , revd. 285 N. Y. 818 ), and Zahn v. City of New York ( 274 App. Div. 807 , affd. 299 N. Y. 581 ). MaeCrate, J., concurs with Carswell, J.
Cases cited
- Williams v. City of New York 214 N. Y. 259 at 263 p. 790
- Bordonaro v. Bank of Blasdell 285 N. Y. 606 p. 790
- Galvano v. City of New York 285 N. Y. 818 p. 790