Fitzgerald v. Smith — 178 Cal. 679

Majority

p. 679

[L. A. No. 5805.

In Bank.

August 5, 1918.]

BOYCE R. FITZGERALD, Petitioner, v. F. E. SMITH, County Clerk, etc., Respondent.

Headnote

Elections — Direct Primary Law — Nomination of Candidates— Offices to be Pilled.—Under the direct primary law, candidates may be nominated at the primary for such offices only as may properly be included in the notices required to be given by section 4 of the law, and where such notices were given prior t'o the resignation of an elective officer, no candidate for such office can be nominated, but must be nominated in the manner prescribed by section 1188 of the Political Code.

APPLICATION for a Writ of Prohibition originally made to the Supreme Court to restrain a county clerk from placing on an official primary election ballot the names of candidates for the office of judge of the Superior Court for an unexpired term.

The facts are stated in the opinion of the court.

Foster & Barnhart, for Petitioner.

Anderson & Borton, for Respondent.

The respondent is about to place on the official primary election ballot to be used in Kern County at the primary election to be held on August 27, 1918, as candidates for the office of judge of the superior court of Kern County for the unexpired term of Honorable Milton T. Farmer, resigned, the names of three candidates who have filed nomination petitions in form as required by the direct primary law. The resignation of Judge Farmer as judge of the superior court of Kern County was not filed until July 11, 1918, on which date it was; by the Governor duly accepted. Coneededly an election for the unexpired term must take place at the next general election to be held in November, 1918, but it is claimed that under the circumstances of this case candidates for such office may not be voted for at the August primary.

We are of the opinion that this claim is well based. The direct primary law requires, for the purpose of acquainting

p. 680

the electors with the names of the offices for which candidates may file nomination petitions and be voted for at the primary election, that certain notices shall be given, the first at least seventy days before the date of the primary by the Secretary of State to the county clerks and registrars, designating all the offices except township offices, for which candidates are to be nominated at such primary election, and the second, one given by the county clerk or registrar in each county and city and county by publication in a newspaper or newspapers published in such county or city and county, commencing /within ten days after receipt by him of such notice from the Secretary of State, which notice shall include a designation of all the offices for which candidates are to be nominated at such primary election. (Direct Primary Law, sec. 4; Stats. 1913, p. 1382, as. amended by Stats. 1917, p. 1344, sec. 3). These notices were given prior to the resignatiori of Judge Farmer and, of course, they did not, and could not, include any designation of this office as one of the offices for which candidates were to be nominated.

We are satisfied that a proper construction of the primary law requires the conclusion that candidates may be nominated at the primary for such offices only as may properly be included in the notices thus provided for. It is the condition existing at the time prescribed by the law for the giving of the notices that controls, in so far as the primary is concerned. For the purposes of the primary the situation here is the same as it would have been if Judge Farmer had not resigned until the time for the filing of nomination' petitions had expired. Under the circumstances no candidate for this office can be nominated at the primary, with the result that the candidates to be voted for for such office at the general election in November must be nominated in the manner prescribed by section 1188 of the Political Code.

It is ordered that the respondent omit from the official primary election ballot to be used at the primary election of August 27, 1918, all mention of the office of judge of the supérior court for the unexpired term of Judge Farmer and of all names of any persons who have filed nomination petitions therefor.