← Cases

Watson v. McClay

4 Cal. 288 Court Cal. English

Judges Mr. Ch. J. Murray concurred.

Delivered by Heydeneeldt J.

Contents

Majority — Heydeneeldt J.

p. 288
* WATSON v McCLAY.

Headnote

New Trial — Discretion.—The exercise of a sound discretion in granting a new triad, upon a review of the facts alone, will not he disturbed.

delivered the opinion of the Court.

Mr. Ch. J. Murray concurred.

Where the Court below, in the exercise of a sound discretion, grants a new trial upon a review of the facts alone, we have always refused to disturb it. _

Footnotes

  1. [1] Cited, 5 Kan. 133 .