p. 464sixth years; of eight days of each month of the seventh and eighth years; of nine days for each month of the ninth and tenth years; and for ten days of each month after ten years. Such credit to be computed in favor of every such convict as a commutation of sentence, and to be deducted from the entire term of penal servitude to which such convict shall have been sentenced; provided that this rule of commutation shall be so applied that any refusal to labor, breach of the prison rules, or other misconduct, shall work a forfeiture of the credits of time thus earned, or such part of it as the Board of State Prison Directors may determine. The power to declare such forfeiture shall rest in the Board of State Prison Directors alone,' or a majority thereof; and time once forfeited shall not be restored, except by a majority of the Board of Directors in such case, and then only when circumstances shall order (render) such restoration urgently necessary.
Section 2. This Act shall apply to all persons now imprisoned in the State Prison, and the commutation herein provided for, shall be computed from April 4, 1864.” (Stats. 1867-8, p. 675.)
Section
1,
590 of the Penal Code re-enacts the foregoing provisions as to the credits to be allowed a convict, and the manner of deducting them from his term of penal servitude.
J. H. McKune, for the Petitioner. The judgment prescribes the time when each term of penal servitude shall begin—the first on January 1, 1866, and the second on January 1, 1876. Each term is a distinct and separate term of penal servitude. The credits to which the prisoner is entitled, having been earned during the first term, should be deducted from that term, and being so deducted, he was entitled to be discharged on the 30th of March, 1874. Hence he is now held without authority, and the writ should be granted.-
Attorney-General Love, contra: The Penal Code, following the language of the original statute, distinctly enacts that the credits shall be deducted from “the entire term of
p. 465penal servitude to which such convict shall have been sentenced.” This language clearly indicates the intention of the Legislature to allow the deduction for good behavior-only from the whole number of years to which a convict may have been sentenced, whether he has been sentenced upon one conviction or several.speaking for the Court, said: The language of the statute is that the credits allowed for the good behavior of a convict, shall be deducted from “the entire term of penal servitude to which he has been sentenced.” The prisoner in this case has been convicted of two offenses, for each of which he has been sentenced to suffer imprisonment in the State Prison for ten years, making twenty years in all as the “entire term” to which he has been sentenced. The Court is of opinion that in such a case “the entire term of penal servitude,” within the intent of the statute, is twenty years. Each period of ten years is but a part of the entire term, and the second follows the first without any hiatus. Whatever deduction is to be made for good behavior, is not to be taken from the beginning or the middle, but from the end of the entire term. We think the prisoner must be remanded, and it is so ordered.