← Cases

Cloud v. Davis

1 Del. Cas. 422 Court Court of Common Pleas. New Castle. English

Delivered by Chief Justice.

Contents

Majority

p. 422
CLOUD v. DAVIS.
Court of Common Pleas. New Castle.
February, 1797 (Adjourned).
Bayard’s Notebook, 175.
Bayard, for the defendant,
objected to the reading of the depositions on the ground that the rule gave no power to take them out of the state.
Vandyke
argued in favor of their admission and insisted that the manner in which they were taken was warranted by practice.

The practice has been invariably to issue a commission when the intention was to take depositions out of the state, unless in the cases where a special rule for the purpose was agreed to by the parties. A general rule to take depositions before any judge or justice of the peace is confined to the state. If the party designs under his rule to take depositions out of the state, he must have it so expressed in the rule. The depositions

p. 423
in the present case are not warranted by the rule under which they were taken and cannot therefore be read.

Depositions rejected.