← Cases

Renwick v. Mack

4 Edw. Ch. 380 Court N.Y. Ch. Decision date 1844-04-02 English

Contents

Majority

p. 380
Renwick by her next friend, v. Mack and others.
April 2, 1844.

Headnote

Where several exceptions are taken for impertinence when one only should have covered the matter, the court will, as to costs, look at it as one exception merely.
Pleading. Answer. Exception for Impertinence. Practice, Costs,
On the argument of the exceptions for impertinence in this case,

The Vice-Chancellor stated that here were three exceptions for impertinence in matter which ought to have been embraced in one exception only; and that, on the question of costs, it would have to be so considered.

Mr. Eddy, for the defendant.

Mr. Dana, for the complainant.