Hyperlawhypertext legal databasebeta Equitable Paper Bag Co. v. Long Island Railroad 172 Misc. 934

← Cases

Equitable Paper Bag Co. v. Long Island Railroad

172 Misc. 934 Court Supreme Court, Appellate Term, First Department, Decision date 1939-11-01 English

Decision Majority — Per Curiam. · Dissent — Hammer, J.

Contents

Majority

p. 934
Equitable Paper Bag Co., Inc., Respondent, v. The Long Island Railroad Company, Appellant.[1]
Supreme Court, Appellate Term, First Department,
November 1, 1939.
Louis J. Carruthers [William McNamara of counsel], for the appellant.
Benjamin Feldstein, for the respondent.

A bailor suing a warehouseman for failure to deliver goods intrusted to him, has the burden of proving the negligence of the bailee. If he proves demand upon the warehouseman and his refusal to deliver, these facts unexplained are prima facie evidence of negligence. If it appears from the proof offered by the plaintiff or the defendant that the loss is due to fire, that fact in itself, in the absence of circumstances permitting the inference of lack of reasonable precautions, does not suffice to show neglect; the plaintiff having the affirmative must in such case go forward with evidence to show negligence. As1 there is no evidence of negligence in this case defendant’s motion for the direction of a verdict should have been granted. (Draper v. D. & H. Canal Co., 118 N. Y. 118 ; Southern R. Co. v. Prescott, 240 U. S. 632 ;

Dissent

p. 935
Liberty Ins. Co. v. Central Vermont R. R. Co., 19 App. Div. 509 .)

Judgment reversed, with costs, and judgment directed in favor of the defendant, with costs. Appeal from order dismissed.

Shientag and Noonan, JJ., concur; Hammer, J., dissents.

I dissent. (See Russell Mfg. Co. v. New Haven Steamboat Co., 50 N. Y. 121 .)

Cases cited