Hyperlawhypertext legal database Dailey v. New York, Ontario & Western Railway Co. 26 Misc. 539

← Cases

Dailey v. New York, Ontario & Western Railway Co.

26 Misc. 539 Court N.Y. Sup. Ct. English

Delivered by Hirschberg, J.

Contents

Majority

p. 539
Ada J. Dailey as Administratrix, etc., of Jonathan H. Dailey, Deceased, Plaintiff, v. The New York, Ontario & Western Railway Co., Defendant.
(Supreme Court, Orange Special Term,
February, 1899.)

Headnote

Action of negligence against foreign corporation — Barred by foreign Statute of Limitations contained in the remedial statute.
Where a foreign statute gives a right unknown to the common law — e. g., the right of the representatives of a decedent to recover damages for his next of kin where his death resulted from negligence — and declares that suit must be brought “ within,' one year after the death, and not thereafter ”, the time limitation measures the extent and qualifies the nature of the statutory right to sue, the same will be enforced by the courts of the state of New York and will bar such an action brought in this state, for an accident' which occurred in the foreign state, by the personal representatives where more than one year has elapsed between the death of the decedent and the commencement of the action.
Demurrer to answer in an action for negligence.
John W. Lyon, for plaintiff.
Vanamee & Vail, for defendant.

The action is to recover damages for the death by negligence of the plaintiff’s decedent in the state of Pennsylvania. One of the defenses is that by the provisions of the Penn

p. 540
sylvania statute giving the right of action, suit must be brought “ within one year after the death and not thereafter ”, and it is alleged that more than one year intervened between the death and the bringing of the suit. The plaintiff demurs.

The cause of action is solely statutory. It is not derivative in any respect, but is an original right conferred by statute upon representatives for the benefit of beneficiaries. It accrues in the place of the transaction, but is enforceable here upon principles of comity. In respect of the right of action the lex loci controls, while all details of the remedy are governed by the lex fori. The right is asserted under the law of the place where it arose, but is measured and determined by means of the law of the place where it is enforced. The period of one year limited by the law of Pennsylvania as that within which the action may be brought relates to and qualifies the right itself. At the end of the year the right is as effectually extinguished by the lapse of time as it would be by actual payment. After that date no right of action existed under the laws of the foreign state, and there is, accordingly, no claim to be enforced under the forms of our remedial laws.

Statutes of limitation may either bar the remedy or qualify the right. In the first case they will be found in the lex fori, in the second ease in the lex loci. In cases of contract generally, and of actionable wrongs recognized by the common law, the suit must be brought within the time prescribed by the law of the place where the remedy is sought, even though the law of the country where the contract was entered into or the wrong committed may allow a much longer time in which to bring an action; and the Statute of Limitations of another state, where the contract was made or wrong perpetrated cannot be pleaded in bar. But where a statute gives a right unknown to the common law, and limits the time within which an action shall be brought to assert it, the statutory limitation measures the extent and qualifies the nature of the right conferred, and will be respected and enforced by the courts of any state wherein the plaintiff may sue. 7 Lawson’s Rights and Remedies, § 3738, and cases cited; Cavanagh v. Ocean Steam Nav. Co., 19 Civ. Pro. 393; The Harrisburgh, 119 U. S. 199 ; Wooden v. W. N. Y. & P. R. R. Co., 126 N. Y. 10 ; Kiefer v. Grand Trunk R. Co., 12 App. Div. 33 ; Hill v. Board of Supervisors, 119 N. Y. 347 . The demurrer is overruled.

Demurrer overruled.

Cases cited