Hyperlawhypertext legal databasebeta People v. Steves 117 Misc. 2d 841

← Cases

People v. Steves

117 Misc. 2d 841 Court Town Court of Webster, Decision date 1983-02-14 English

Delivered by C. Benn Forsyth, J.

Contents

Majority

p. 841
The People of the State of New York, Plaintiff, v Mark Steves, Defendant.
Town Court of Webster,
February 14, 1983
APPEARANCES OF COUNSEL
Donald O. Chesworth, Jr., District Attorney {John Gilbert of counsel), for plaintiff. Mark Steves, defendant pro se.

OPINION OF THE COURT

The defendant was charged with violation of section 1193-a of the Vehicle and Traffic Law for failure to take a so-called screening test. The facts are not in dispute. The defendant was arrested upon this charge and a charge of speeding. The court finds there was adequate cause to require a screening test under section 1193-a. The defendant refused to take the screening test and was given the ticket in question. The issue is whether or not a violation of section 1193-a is an infraction. The section has no punishment included.

The Court of Appeals has decided that there is no constitutional right to refuse to take an alcoholic test {People v Thomas, 46 NY2d 100 ). Section 1193-a requires no “commissioner warnings” to the effect that failure to take the test may result in a penalty. It is clear that the Legislature did not intend to permit a motorist to decline to take this test, if the proper circumstances were present. The court holds that the Legislature has placed upon the driver a constitutionally valid obligation. The failure to comply is as much a violation of this law as speeding or disobeying any other traffic law.

p. 842
The remaining issue is whether the failure to specify the penalty prevents criminal enforcement. Section 1193-a does not state that the failure to take the test is a traffic infraction. However, section 1800 of the Vehicle and Traffic Law states that it is a traffic infraction (unless a misdemeanor is specified) for any person to violate any of the provisions of the Vehicle and Traffic Law. The court finds that this is a proper exercise of legislative authority and the provisions of section 1800 are incorporated into section 1193-a. The two sections together describe the offense and punishment. The court, therefore, finds the defendant guilty and sets the matter down for sentence on March 2, 1983 at 7:00 p.m.

Cases cited