← Cases

Ernst v. Good Samaritan Hospital

86 Misc. 694 Court District Court of Suffolk County, Decision date 1976-04-16 English

Delivered by Paul Creditor, J.

Contents

Majority

p. 694
Michael Ernst, an Infant by His Mother and Natural Guardian, Olga Ernst, et al., Plaintiffs, v Good Samaritan Hospital, Defendant, and Soe Thein, Third-Party Defendant.
District Court of Suffolk County,
April 16, 1976
Barry, McTiernan, Moore & Siracuse for defendant. Soe Thein, third-party defendant pro se. Bernard M. Rosen for plaintiffs.

The defendant moves first for an order pursuant to section 148-a of the Judiciary Law to set this controversy down before a medical malpractice panel; and second, for an order setting the third-party action down for an inquest because the third-party defendant has defaulted.

p. 695
Section 148-a of the Judiciary Law directs each Appellate Division of the Supreme Court to establish medical malpractice panels to facilitate the disposition of medical malpractice actions in Supreme Court. The statute in its present form and as twice amended, clearly indicates that malpractice panels are to apply only to Supreme Court actions. (L 1974, ch 146; L 1974, ch 657.) Thus, District Court lacks jurisdiction to order an action to be set down before the Supreme Court malpractice panel.

Therefore, defendant’s motion in this regard, must be denied.

Defendant’s second request is to schedule an inquest for the third-party action because the third-party defendant is in default. The entry of a default judgment in a third-party action is not required prior to the determination of liability in the main action. (Multari v Glalin Arms Corp., 28 AD2d 122 , 124.)

It appears that this request is premature, and accordingly, it is denied.

So ordered.

Cases cited