Stakel v. City of Batavia — 260 N.Y. 628

Majority

p. 628

Viola Stakel, Respondent, v. City of Batavia, Appellant.

(Argued October 21, 1932;

decided November 22, 1932.)

p. 629

Clayton M. Smith and Fred Van Aernam for appellant.

Walter J. Davison for respondent.

Judgment of the Appellate Division and that of the Trial Term reversed, and complaint dismissed, with costs in all courts, on the authority of Hamilton v. City of Buffalo ( 173 N. Y. 72 ); Butler v. Village of Oxford ( 186 N. Y. 444 ); Terry v. Village of Perry ( 199 N. Y. 79 ); Lalor v. City of New York ( 208 N. Y. 431 ). No opinion.

Concur: Lehman, Kellogg, O’Brien and Hubbs, JJ. Dissenting: Pound, Ch. J., and Crane, J. Not sitting: Crouch, J.

Cases cited

Hamilton v. City of Buffalo 173 N. Y. 72 N.Y. 1903-01-06 p. 629
Butler v. Village of Oxford 186 N. Y. 444 N.Y. 1906-12-18 p. 629
Terry v. Village of Perry 199 N. Y. 79 N.Y. 1910-06-07 p. 629
Lalor v. City of New York 208 N. Y. 431 N.Y. 1913-05-20 p. 629