Majority
p. 385Isaac Mendelsohn, Respondent, v. Joseph Rosenberg, Appellant, Impleaded with Others. Submitted March 2, 1937; decided March 23, 1937. The order is not a final order affecting a substantial right, and is one made in the exercise of discretion, and is not reviewable by the Court of Appeals. (Klasko Finance Corp. v. Belleaire Hotel Corp., 257 N. Y. 1 ; Geller v. Flamount Realty Corp., 260 N. Y. 346 .)
Lloyd B. Kanter for appellant.
Benjamin Cohen for respondent.
Although this court allowed the appeal in this cause, it has been called to our attention that the
p. 386
order is not appealable. (Matter of Steinman v. Conlon, 208 N. Y. 198 ; Hand v. Ortschreib Building Corp., 254 N. Y. 15 . See Jewelers’ Mercantile Agency v. Jewelers’ Weekly Pub. Co., 155 N. Y. 241 .) We, therefore, do not pass on the merits but reserve the question until properly before us for review.
The appeal should be dismissed, with costs.
Crane, Ch. J., Lehman, O’Brien, Hubbs, Loughran, Finch and Rippey, JJ., concur.
Appeal dismissed.
Cases cited
- Klasko Finance Corp. v. Belleaire Hotel Corp. 257 N. Y. 1 p. 385
- Geller v. Flamount Realty Corp. 260 N. Y. 346 p. 385
- Steinman v. Conlon 208 N. Y. 198 p. 386
- Hand v. Ortschreib Building Corp. 254 N. Y. 15 p. 386
- Jewelers' Mercantile Agency v. Jewelers' Weekly Publishing Co. 155 N. Y. 241 p. 386