Hyperlawhypertext legal database E. Osborne Smith, Inc. v. Weiss 296 N.Y. 909

← Cases

E. Osborne Smith, Inc. v. Weiss

296 N.Y. 909 Court N.Y. Decision date 1947-02-28 English

Decision Majority · Dissent — Fttld, J.,

Contents

Majority

p. 909
E. Osborne Smith, Inc., Appellant, v. Meyer Weiss, Respondent.
Submitted January 15, 1947;
decided February 28, 1947.
p. 910
Karl Propper for appellant.
Edmond B. Butler and Myron P. Gordon for respondent.

Judgments reversed and a new trial granted, with costs to abide the event, upon the ground that evidence received without

Dissent

p. 911
objection was sufficient to support the verdict upon the theory of the court’s charge, to which no exception was taken.

Concur: Loughean, Ch. J., Lewis, Conway, Desmond, Thachee and Dye, JJ.

dissents in the following memorandum: In order to succeed in this action, plaintiff broker was under the necessity of proving a contract with defendant that the latter would deal only through it and would refuse to purchase the property through any other broker. In my view, plaintiff has failed to establish such a contract. (Foss v. N. Y. C. & H. R. R. R. Co., 217 N. Y. 727 ; Sieven v. Glazer, 267 App Div 969 , leave to appeal denied, 292 N. Y. 726 .)

Cases cited