Mirabella v. Thiem — 306 N.Y. 650

Majority

p. 650

Frank Mirabella, Appellant, v. Alvin F. Thiem, Doing Business under the Name of Pine Tree Riding Stables, Respondent.

Argued October 22, 1953;

decided December 3, 1953.

p. 652

Joseph W. Alaimo and Philip B. Dattilo for appellant.

Eric P. Smith for respondent.

Judgments reversed and a new trial granted, with costs to abide the event, upon the ground that the evidence presented questions of fact for the jury. No opinion.

Concur: Lewis, Ch. J., Conway, Dye and Froessel, JJ. Desmond and Fuld, JJ., dissent on the memorandum of the Appellate Division. Taking no part: Van Voorhis, J.