Repper v. Patterson — 306 N.Y. 683

Majority

p. 683

In the Matter of Virginia Repper, on Behalf of Herself and All Other Residents and Property Owners in Harbor Island, Island Park, Nassau County, Similarly Situated, Appellant, against A. Holly Patterson et al., Constituting the Town Board of the Town of Hempstead, Respondents, and Oil Products, Inc., et al., Interveners, Respondents.

Argued October 20, 1953;

decided January 14, 1954.

p. 685

Jules B. St. Germain for appellant.

George W. Foley, Ghauncey B. Garver and Robert L. Glare, Jr., for Boykin C. Wright, amicus curia, in support of appellant’s position.

John A. Morhous, Acting Town Attorney, for A. Holly Patterson and others, respondents, and Louis 0. Bergh for Oil Products, Inc., intervener-respondent.

Alexander Kronhart for Walter M. Allen and others, amici curia, in support of respondents’ position.

This proceeding was brought pursuant to article 78 of the Civil Practice Act to review refusal by the town board of the Town of Hempstead to consent, pursuant to section 348 of the Village Law, to a petition for annexation of territory to the village of Island Park. We find in the record herein substantial evidence upon which the town board could find, as it did, that the petition lacked signatures of a majority of the persons residing within the territory proposed to be annexed to the village, who were qualified to vote for town officers when the petition was filed with the town clerk and acted upon by the town board. Accordingly, the order dismissing the petition should be affirmed.

We note, however, that it is no longer necessary that a petition for annexation of a territory contain signatures both of owners of a majority in value of the assessed property therein, and of

p. 686

a majority of the persons residing therein qualified to vote for town officers (L. 1927, ch. 650, § 44). We pass on no other question.

The order should be affirmed, with costs.

Lewis, Ch. J., Conway, Desmond, Dye, Fuld, Froessel and Van Voorhis, JJ., concur.

Order affirmed.