Majority
p. 773In the Matter of John T. McManus et al., Respondents, against Carmine G. DeSapio, as Secretary of State, et al., Appellants. Argued October 24, 1958; decided October 24, 1958.
p. 774
Abraham J. Gellinoff for appellants.
David M. Freedman and Morris Zuckman for respondents.
Order affirmed; no opinion.
Concur: Chief Judge Conway and Judges Dye, Fuld, Froessel and Van Voorhis. Judges Burke and McGivern[1] dissent and vote to reverse upon the authority of Matter of Anderson v. Power ( 1 A D 2d 603 , affd. 1 N Y 2d 868 ), Matter of Marcatante v. Lundy ( 4 A D 2d 883 , revd. on dissenting-memorandum below 3 N Y 2d 913 ), Matter of Warsoff v. Cohen ( 289 N. Y. 108 ), Matter of Connors v. Messina ( 308 N. Y. 877 ), and Matter of Bailey v. Power ( 5 N Y 2d 746 ).
* Designated pursuant to section 5 of article VI of the State Constitution in the temporary absence of Judge Desmond.
Cases cited
- Anderson v. Power 1 N Y 2d 868 p. 774
- Marcatante v. Lundy 3 N Y 2d 913 p. 774
- Warsoff v. Cohen 289 N. Y. 108 p. 774
- Connors v. Messina 308 N. Y. 877 p. 774
- Bailey v. Power 5 N Y 2d 746 p. 774