Majority
Headnote
1. Evidence (§ 420*)—Parol Evidence—Admissibility.This action is brought to recover damages for breach of contract arising out of defendant’s cancellation of an order for calendars placed by him with plaintiff. The evidence shows that on the 17th day of February, 1908, plaintiff’s salesman, one Camp-stein, procured of the defendant a written order for calendars for which defendant agreed to pay on delivery. The said order was forwarded to plaintiff by its salesman, and on the 30th day of February, 1908, plaintiff notified defendant of its acceptance of said order. The order, signed by this defendant, contained, among others, the following provisions, printed in plain type directly over the space bearing defendant’s signature, viz.:
“These goods are to be specially made, and this order is not subject to countermand after its acceptance by Metropolitan Aluminum Mfg. Co. No special arrangements or promises of any kind by agents will be recognized, unless expressly written in this order and approved of by Metropolitan Aluminum Manufacturing Co.”
On or about March 10, 1908, the defendant addressed a communication to the plaintiff, canceling the order signed by him on the 17th day of February, 1908, and claiming that prior to the signing of the order by him he had informed plaintiff’s salesman that he (defendant) had
Judgment reversed and new trial ordered, with costs to appellant to abide the event. All concur.
Cases cited
- Reynolds v. Robinson 110 N. Y. 654 p. 1061
- Mayer v. Dean 115 N. Y. 556 p. 1061
- Beck v. Donohue 27 Misc. Rep. 230 p. 1061
- Joseph v. Struller 25 Misc. Rep. 173 p. 1061
- Legnard v. Standard Life & Accident Ins. 81 App. Div. 320 p. 1061
- Messelback v. Norman 122 N. Y. 578 p. 1061