Majority
p. 872Charde et al., Resp’ts, v. City of Brooklyn, App’lt. Simms, Resp’t, v. Same, App’lt. Ct. Ap., October 22, 1895.
Albert G. McDonald and It. B. Greenwood,, Jr., for app’lt; Oscar Frisbie, for resp’ts Charde ; Eseh Gowen, for resp’t Simms.
No opinion. Judgment affirmed in Simms case. Judgment reversed in'the Charde case on the opinions of general term in the Simms case, with costs. 87 Hun, 35 . All concur. Charde case, rev’g 61 St. Rep. 51 ; Simms case, aff’g 67 St. Rep. 611 .