← Cases

In re the American Surety Co.

51 N.Y. Super. Ct. 531 19 Jones & S. 531 Court N.Y. Super. Ct. Decision date 1885-02-02 English

Contents

Majority

p. 531
IN THE MATTER OF THE APPLICATION OF THE AMERICAN SURETY Co. for a Rule, &c.
Decided February 2, 1885.
Before Sedgwick, Van Vorst and Freedman, JJ.
Elihu Root, for the application.

The rule asked is substantially a repetition of the statute on the subject, and this statute has now been so often construed in cases reported, that a rule is not needed for the practical application of the statute. If there should be, the opinion of the court being that there is not anything in a rule of the kind which might be intended to direct what the court at special, term should do in each particular litigation, such a rule would contravene the statute which intends that each application shall be passed upon on its own merits after hearing both sides.

The application should be denied.