Ontario (1) affirming the judgment of the Divisional .
Court in favour of the plaintiffs.
The action was brought by the County of Halton to recover -a bonus paid to the Hamilton and North- Western Railway Co. in aid of their road, the company having executed a bond in favour of the county one of the conditions of which was that the bonus should be repaid " in the event of the company, during the period of twenty-one years, ceasing to be an independent company."
Four years after the company became merged in the Grand Trunk system, and on the trial it was held that it had ceased thereby to be an independent line. Judgment was accordingly given in favour the county which was affirmed by the Divisional Court and the Court of Appeal.
The Supreme Court affirmed this decision for the reasons given in the Court of Appeal, and held that the county was entitled to recover the whole amount of the bonus as unliquidated damages under the bond. S. H. Blake Q.C. and W. Cassels Q.C. for the appellants.
Robinson Q.C. and Bain Q.C. for the respondents. APPEAL-Cantinned.
streets-Duty
3-Monthly alleal repair-Municipalit--By-law--Vlidity lit lroviices-Per 5-Solicitor-Bill taxation- Discretioe-Prceedieg ariinatim Court-Finul R.S.O. Duois v. [S. C. R. VoL. XXI. APPEAL-Continued.
APPEAL-Contiucd.
8-Mining lands-Barnae Jerisdic- JJ., lion-R.
ters.-Per J.-The Supr-ie
Court.-Per
9-FiialidgmeiilAdtiou 6-Supreme 3-Appeal nder appeal-Arts. jadiceta Praetice-Jdgmcnt JJ.-That services-Retainer-Appeal AfutzelservecsRctanerAppel firm-Held, 3.-A 12-Election petition-Judgment voiding of-Six ofjudgment-R.S.C. appeal-Discontintunce-Effect Pract
Registrar-New 14-Order trial-Interference 15-Expropriation land-Value 16-Fraudulent creditor-Amount controversy-Jurisdicby-Municipal TAXES-Insurance fund-Deposit G(overnment [N.B.])-The KES-Continued. 2--Tax fore-Departure of-Appeal BY-LAW-ofMunicipal Corporatioi-Validy road-Appeal-Future Corporaion-Publication - CASES-Abrath SALE-Affidavitofbonufides-Adherform-Description grantor-R.
of.......
with.-Per J.-The
-Action-Mining lands-Injunction
3-Bernardin 4--Commercial 5-Grindley approved 6-Hannon 7-Hurtubise PRIVILEGE-Arts.
C.-Expert-Duties
11-Shau; procs- 12delart strictissimijuris.
MORTGAGE-Continued.
LAW-Continued. advance-Prefer- Power part-Effect instrument-R.S.
serrice-Reneneration.j hit Art.
425 xith 72Court court performaice atd imch LAW-Administrat 2-C'onstructtott of-Catting Sistice-C-tiisal l-That ss. victal efitethe judgueit Iigs firlements at smaer tanhs district other that cotsy aid 3-Application quard.-Eiden isure nder parliamnt fied
:Held, ''any follos powersat kindiand
Hews b-l el, court
Goynne Jeds sning, hat th corpot purcha acnotano at niii
\t-c building-auterials 4--Specific for lie note-Suspenion governed, agreeiit-Eideece. ] NEGLIGENCE-Usc t.
ELECTIONS-Elction tion-Statis ofpetitioner-Preliminary ofvotrs-Dominion affiring 6omcnenciiaiutoftrial-Six Discontiance-£ertuficate L'AssoiToN would'e of-44 'unada-Infornation-R.S. ScireFicias-Form C.CP.-Subscription coipaiy tine i Act-R. Ptiority-iortiqe-Rectiftcationof fide thcopaneffectually ;and motages ot thejudmneit aaint fie.Held, affirming the judgment of theai' erroneously designated in the pleadings as deig ofth DEED-Fraudaleit Estoppe-lutualitycVlidating conpany-Manaer-Prontisby-Liability
PDOEMSSOT
3---Foreign-Joing lads-Injury ion- Pant ian-Order policy-A -Jurisdietioss-Disrretiort-Pro- Tite
-(rant Solicitor re'uit-Poarol eridese frce LAW-Speedy
2-Notary-Conrorissioit crie-Civil
409a
Louisnuc
-Booms-Proprietary rights- RIGHTS.
judgmnt loss-Proof retaitder Preliminary er-Proof-Voters' ent
EXPERT-Builder's exicutor-Purchase
Procts-rcrbal-Arts. 4-A1fortgage- Award- Se a-Promissory note-laker ity-Intention pelfrone
FIRE.
ation-Proceeiso grantor-Onus proof-355 stance julicta trial-Death plaintiff-Reading jury-Misrepresentation
359 4--Appeal frotiIterloeutory decision-Lisiitiie
-Inproper admission-Reverdict-New trial harbour-Title to-(Irentfroni -Estappel-Validating goodfreith ise-Ese- ]RittE.
against-Legacy--Trust-Clai
RIGRTS-Mtniciplb-lan.-Vtlielito of-Repairofroad-ES.C. ds-Bortige-Ijunetion batktleim for loss-Proofofelaine Aecotttstles.] ajd aa GUARANTEE-Contiied. thin aents assumiing J.-That iiine WIFE-Married hus-biul-Iepleviz ai againt she judgment Hanoa doiy itcome-Deictioi-Tx TAXES. ient and all saie policy.-Hd, shipped-Held, jury.-Per siers McLEitLAN insuraneaverage-Issurance hull-Cost atiri 3-Appication-A'eement aside-Scire JUDGMENT-egistry Priority Act-Judge court-Tevritoria uisdiccriiinal arrcte-Neis LEGACY-Residary LIBEL-Personal ''We trial: LIEN-Mechanic's-Materials
LIEN-Materials tractor-Payment 406 tractor-Payment acontractorwith materials PRSECTION Resonbleendnote cause-Belief prosecutor-Duty inquiry-Questions for jury.]
this result part Corporation-Drainage-Injury by-Rentedy-R.
my re-Keglience- 325, Sparkarrester-Net trial-App-af mortgageel tiia partis ocediys-Ordt wiwards, butin wasmen unetan 8600h Ins creitos sonc ed agdorece wichwas coplet anwer tahiner-Defcti usage-Liabiity eister ijurics ijuries workan
2th isjures defectie
2th tan unertat.
H-Seldi reersing te judgn aid pro tnto, the had right to MORTGAGE-Continud.
J.-1. purchase-Conditions t.
mvorttae-Purchase by-Trust.] sold.
at aid, RY.
4-Uniregistered-Judgnment by-Registry of-Priority-Mistake lands-Injury -Reedy far- 5--Chattel aortgage-Affidarit fidesstreets-Duty repair-Transferred I stre'ts, away.-By rilits, adjoiing.
sant sas thata section.-Per WATEus 5--BY-lau-Submison statutc-impcratire MunicipalAct-liS.O. ionM-anrepair-Notice.] wthin djiiin affiring HtoN Rihts infatut road-Road charter-P-5.0. 42(0.)
yine-Disrharye ofsleam-iuisancc contined 44.)-Held, anythig, shici ijures eitled J arrester-Char/ toiur-Misirection-Ne'tial 3-Application Se for-lisdi- 3-Master 3--Action ofplaintff
4-Action 4OTARY-Noariot
5-Use os ofNotaries-Diciplinr, poers-P injuri an tiaonPta rivereill croration itis ation-Rpair thata 2-Estoppet-Title Iatore-Conreyanee statte.-Per amendg the.istie.i fi of-Arts. Railay cithout notice.-Per Pit aainst JJ-Notice perfornce ofthem priorlabour.
atongst 3-Solicitorn Rtainer tle 4--Notariat
A/tarie.-Disciplinarp jurisdition Canade-Soliritor reruit-Parot eeideoe-Art. fn perty-Iesurrble
Libcl-Personal bn Jueneral verdictNeo PRACTICE-Misdiretioe neatter. wre iligece Plintiff tie trejury wat jstificaicenceed
;have co.-Dreinion tiat
Doinion Parliamet
7-Malicious inquiry-Questions jury.]
Q.
8-Judgment report-redibility ant;
ofparties-Substitution-Prejudice
10-Action fide for part instrument-R.S.0.
endorser-Intention
2--Form of-" words-Liability pirrights-Beplevin-Revendica- Q., charge-Pled Art. of-Arts. fin nort judgient rights-llcveu dicetion-Estppel
Riiurs.
Petitionfar chartr- Maintnane reed-P. SALEOF
LAND-Under Judynent Staitte N.B.-Agent
TUSE
2-Sheriff's rConstructiont tion-Registry-Judgment
2-Mortgage-Description
Act-R.S.N.S.
judgment-Priorityinsurance-Insurancc hull-Salvage Joint
J.-Except OFF-Solicitors-Action '735 ajainst-Trespass
SOLICITQR-ontinued.
Justif cation-Proof WIFE.
Btt
Guarantes -- Evidence - Misrepresentation.] - On a
Evdene totheCourt court tertin section.-Per J.-The maning aid iot cort.-Pe orde matte
2-Proceedings esd 6aneda-Sotieiter 4-Action -Betainsr-Appeal-Jurisdiet him.-Held,
ERe
RMNCto]
gr akebus libleon ship-Insurance Ihen
42-Appeal-Jurisdiction court-Final party [S. C. R. VoL. XXI. ANCE-Continued.
STATUTE-Continued.
coie 2-Contract sus 3.., 390 2-Title land-Forshore 3-Municipal fegislatsc-Conllrming lidity corporation-Drainage lands-Injury for-Arbitration-Notice
Mnicpal
11..0.[187]pleaded efmg an ompany hain justifed Co.tias statute; covenants-After leiscudb te jdgmet theCout ofAp-which nt 3-Munieipul Act-B.S.0. 583-Drainage lie. r.
(0.)-Application road-Injanction.]
-Application-B.S.0.
4-Chattel advance-fortgage for part creditors.-If 6---Bill fdes-Adform-R.S.N.S. 7--By-law-Submission rate-payers-Publi- 8-Assessment form-Departure r. and 65, 69, 422 Trials
18-53
19-36 Piers
20-44
Art.
8. Art.
DgBTOR
26-25
Toen
28-52
LIMITATIONS-Sherit's exeutor-Pur- TIME-Essence expiry-Waiver
LAND-Foreshore harbour-Crant grante-Objection of-Pleading.] ants.-After land-Sheriff's sale-Executor-Judgof-Purchase tor-Possession-Statute LAND-Continued.
give
4-Purchaser title-Purmoney-Distribution-Trustee.]
(P.Q.)-Toll bridge-Franchise of-Free
BRIDGE-Continued.
granted.
act-R. 2-Mortgage-Railway Will-Construction-Substitution nce-Time property-Declaration of-Muteriality risk WILL-Legacy-Words of-Substitutionsale-Efect of-Art. :-Fifthly, WILL-Continued. for-Appeal-Amount