Ontario affirming the judgment of the Queen's Bench Division which dismissed the appellant's action. The Algoma Trading Co., one of the appellants and plaintiffs, leased certain crown lands to the respondent Shea, the lease containing a covenant by Shea not to remove gravel or sand from the premises. Shea afterwards ascertained that no patent for the land had been issued to the company and applied to the Crown Lands Department for a patent thereof to himself and also sold gravel off the premises to the Canadian Pacific Railway Co.
The plaintiff Co. then pressed the claim they had previously made to the Department and the Commissioner of Crown Lands ruled that it should issue to them on payment to Shea for his improvements. Shea refusing to agree to any terms of compensation the company served him with a notice of arbitration and an award was eventually made which was not taken up as Shea refused to pay his share of the arbitrators' fees. The company having assigned their patent to the plaintiff Boulton, an action was brought by him and the company against Shea claiming arrears of rent, payment for use and occupation, damages for breach the covenant not to remove gravel and delivery of pos- The Supreme Court, Gwynne J. dissenting, affirmed the decision of the Court of Appeal that plaintiffs were not in a position to bring the action until Shea had been paid for his improvements.
Mac Gregor for the appellants.
Watson Q. C., for the respondents.
I1\
T I10
.
AFFIDAVIT-Accompanying form-R.S.N.S.
APPEAL-Election trials- 50-Ruling
2-Jurisdiction court-Final judgment-B.
to.-In jury- juryparties-Railway
APPEAL-Continued.
Ry. Co. appeal-54 dissenting.-Per J.-That statute trial-Appeal for-Final APPEAL-Continued.
appeal-B.
ASSESSMENT AND TAXES ahre secareofothe issssis esonein rside, , andig 8--Jurisdiction-Right appeal-54 4-Amount dispute-B. ial beundestod hatde-were meaingof Irvine
2-Assessment taxes-Taxan raiay-Nova Act-Exemption-Mining railsay febvre R. that no appeal railway constructed and $1,129-Ao-nt BRIDGES-Jurisdiction wide-Ontario
Act-R.S.O. as.
-- BY-LAW
BY-LAW-Continued.
Of trade-Partial prohibition-Res-Ontariu CARRIER-Of defect-Arts. 721 CASES-Archibald 2--Attorney distinguishl
5--Couture 6--Dunfresne 7--Ewart Cr. 246 9--Hunter S..B. 10--Monette - -- -- 11---O'Brien, 12-O'Shea P.D. 13--Queen, Farrell CASES-ontinued.
14-Smith
15-Smith
16-Williams Irvine
CHATTEL fides-Compliance form-R.S.N.S.
at
COMPANY-Continued.
nullt CONSTITUTIONAL
LAW
CIVIL CODE-Arts.
315 nder letters-pateit under great British CODE OF CIVIL
PROCEDURE- Art.
Arts.
COMPANY-Stock in-Payment paid up-Legality judgen eIId, rights-Exeise of-Territorial seal-Suits CONSTITUTIONAL LAW-Continued.
CONSTITUTIONAL LAW-Continued. Court-Jurisdiction.] leglature rights.-The therein.-The adiinis- Act-33 2-Powers lreseit
Qucre-Per statutes-Right
Council-B.N.A. CONTEMPT OF COURT-Appel-Jurisproeceding-Final R.
pceeding se. mnt CONTRACT-Agreement, cultiated. nr To enditure wrds
[S. C. R. VoL. XXII. CONTRACT-Continued.
CONTRACT-Continued.
land-Building tion-Street grantor-Character womanSeparate estate-C.S.U. (0)-R. railway-Surety maker-Reservationofrightsaainst 479 ticket-Implied J.-The CONTROVERTED ELECTIONS-Electrials-R. of-Delivery to-Dama. ges-Arts.
inter CRIMINAL LAW-Criminal
CROWN--Crant from-Disseisin land-Railway Britisk lands-Pre-emption-Federal rights-47
3-Territorial rights-Exercise
Court-nformation action-Practice
DAMAGES-Action
DEBTOR AND CREDITOR-Continued. directors-Part paid DEED-Sale land-Building DEBTOR AND
CREDITOR-Married nt-Disseisinofgrantee C.S.U.C.
EDUCATION-Poers tares-Manitoba 2-B. ESTOPFEL-Trespass pnssrsinn- Se
2-Coveyance sonen-Effect EVIDENCE 210 under-Dealing sith time-Presold-Person trust-Poster
EVIDENCE-Continued.
MANDATE-Continued.
Municipal corporation-Ownership of restrained paying balance to viae-Presumption-Re- the parties
276 compensation and pending the a sequestrator appointed faith-Admission-Judiciul
364 transactions they the terms See
2.the action FINAL JUDGMENT-Contempt of Court-. tie ground that 2--New trial-Appeal
132 the Superior Court dismissing the first action GUARANTEE-of
542 the Court dismissing the action: reversing the judgment the HUSBAND ANDWIFE-Married having right to put P. mandate direct therefore woman-Separate until the account ordered the c. (O)-B.S.O. and action T. c.
210 remain the hands sequestrator appointed with the consent the parties.
BuR v. - Ded education-Lgislative c. 3s.22s.s.2-B.N.A.Aets. 93s.s.3. 577 INSURANCE-Guarantee
542 MORTGAGE-Practice- actionpropert-Fi'st INVENTION- Under the result-Previous
178 Judicature Act the the equity redemption maintain JURISDICTION le Gwynne J. dissenting-NMortgagees out LANDLORD AND TENANT-Rental princi- trespasand 167 injury committed title. Per LEGISLATURE-Power Acts-Rights therefor after parted Constitutional Act-Appeal LESSOR AND LESSEEthe nort- 742 debt.
MANDATE
Partnership
-By-len-Bonus a contre-lettre of-Orderfor to-Ilgal immoralcousideition-Purchaser defee 510 fl
MORTGAGE-Continued.
4--Chattel form-R.S.N.S.
IVIUNICIPAL CORPORATION-By-law vice-R.S.N.S.
contra.-In
Halifax.-The Nova
MUNICIPAL CORPORATION 3-Ontario stream-B.S. 4-Assessment taxes-Ontario 65-Illegal ment-Court at trades-Prohibition streets-Ontario NEGLIGENCE-Continual.
iito
6--By-la-Bonus-Conditions 5cc
NEGLIGENCE-Loading precaution-Liability deredanewtrial.
byte rght 2-Negligence-Proximate cause-Danger volunranoutin rontof hemdeath, gan run.
at ran out in front them a
4-Streef rriltey-Height reiis-Stetutory obligtioe-Arcidest wharf-Invitation plce icharf-Proximate
Riltrey pessenger-Troin tonplotforre-Dnmrrges-Nglgence.] L.wasthe tuning PATENT OF INVENTION-Continucd. POWER OF ATTORNEY-Assignment -Credit
PRACTICE
30-Judicial seted leti- Sec rail-Latent 2-Appeal jury-Withdrawal 721 jury NEW TRIAL-Appeal for-Jurisdiction-Final
2--Action for jury
NOTICE
Breacho eiter policy-- NUISANCE-Street rails-Statutory
PATENT OF INVENTION-Combination result-Previous crit-Setting foron Awritissued Iivi- [S. C. R. VoL. XXII. PRACTICE-Continued.
4--Trial-Disagreement jury-Question trial-Judicature
-Jurisdiction-Final
PRACTICE- Practice-Parties action-Trespass property-First connitted title.-Per J.-A 7-Conveyance-Illegal for rile Infornation judicata-Beneficial sale-Arts. P.-Jurisdiction.] Farinlf S.C.R. JJ. inforiatin Canada surrender or tervenent-Joint
PRESCRIPTION-Purchase of land-Regisof-Presumption faith-Art.
PRINCIPAL AND
AGENT trustee-Authority
RAILWAY COMPANY-Title landby-Railway ats-C.S.C. (Gs. 1-24 489 2-Assessment taxes-Tax Act-Excmptin-Mining rail by-.
PROMISSORY NOTE-Accomniodation- Bys.1thefirsthart nt aid toied
;first sint train-Liabiliy coipny-&'enerat indorser-Surety [S. C. R. VTo. RAILWAY COMPANY-Continued.
SALE OF GOODS-Continued.
2---Person trut-Power trustee-Authority name-Eridene-489 Uu
498 SERVITUDE-Action-Beatorappa tude-Begistrntion-44 Q.)-Art. C.Proeduretpe
Queen's aid seectontestngla l6ss.
Train Sec
~.of
RES JUDICATA-Information tlat Farrell fait SHERIFF-Sale
STATUTE-Construction of-54 Farrell nt standig SALE OF GOODS-ontract for ance-Arts.
315 peding STATUTE-Continued.
2-Crnstruction of-Title land-Tenant by-Railway as. 1-24 grves of-Married
(0.)-R.
of-Municipal r-Street act-Constructionof.]
deeied
STATUTE-Continued.
title-Intention (N.S.)-Application 6--Ontario Act-Br idyes-Width strear-B. 7--Ontario arent-Validation-R. 8-Application of-54 3-Appeal [S. C. R. Vot. XXII. STATUTE-Continued.
intra
10-Construction
30-Judicial
Noa Act-Tax raiby-R.
3-Applicat
Court-Amount
13--Bailway prior rights-Lands
C.)-47
14-R.S.N.S. 4-Chaitel form--563
15-3anitoba
STATUTE OF MAINTENANCE-Con- STATUTES-32 3-C.S.U.C. - 0-33 - - British STATUTE OF MAINTENANCE-Title land-rowcn grant-Disseisin grantee-Torhusband-Statute
9-Statute limitations.]I tie
Echequer 328, 331, 347 [0encrallailay 498 12-54 108,328,331 13-35 [arried STATUTES-Continued.
SURETY-Contin
15-47 &c.
eld, that 447 GwynneJJ. dissenting.
2-Suret,
300 Proissor naoteDischarge 19-44 and'6 Appal, maker 20-R.
. 5 c. [Hihcay.]G
- - - - - - defalcation Diligence.] guarantee surng the honestyof A., granted 22-R.S.N.S. 563 23-50 the guarantors that the
49ploye entailig STOCKI directors-Portion paid
SURETY-Interference
0G., tractors the that
-542 TENANT FOR railthe eecuted.
After
1-24 assent with
TITLE TO LAND-cbulnicipa palyents ad aper
J.
TITLE TO LAND-Continued.
faith-Arts.
C.-Judicial admission-Art.
C.-Art.
dissenting.-In
TITLE TO LAND-Continued. 4-Tenant for acts-C.S.C. 6-Old f
TRADE
TRESPASS-on
Scshh Cns'usc~mN grant-Disseisin grantee-Tortious husband-Statute Aainten- 9-Statute iig lie, tie nder for- TRUSTEE- Will-Executorsand one-Notice-Inquiry.]
cussed.-W.
creditors-Power assignor-Sale assignor-Authority
VENDOR AND PURCHASER-Agreesell-Title will-Restriction-Part contract-Place
'WILL of-Division
WILL-Continued.
provision:-But 2-Executors under-Breach one-Dealing trust-Notice-Inquiry WRIT-Of under-Order