Chase v. Phillips — 223 U.S. 715

Majority

p. 715

No. 554.

Horace Chase, Individually and as Administrator, etc., Plaintiff in Error, v. Leonard H. Phillips and Samuel C. Lawrence, Trustees.

Syllabus

In error to the Supreme Judicial Court of the State of Massachusetts.

Motion to dismiss or affirm submitted January 22, 1912.

Decided February 19, 1912.

Mr- Richard Y. FitzGerald for the plaintiff in error. Mr. J. L. Thorndike and Mr. E. R. Thayer for the defendants in error.

Dismissed for the want of jurisdiction. Farrell v. O’Brien, 199 U. S. 89 , 100; San Francisco v. Itsell, 133 U. S. 65 ; Empire State-Idaho Mining Co. v. Hanley, 205 U. S. 225 , 235-236; Chase v. Phillips, 216 U. S. 616 .

Cases cited

Farrell v. O'Brien 199 U. S. 89 SCOTUS 1905-05-29 p. 715
San Francisco City v. Itsell 133 U. S. 65 SCOTUS 1890-01-20 p. 715
Empire State-Idaho Mining & Developing Co. v. Hanley 205 U. S. 225 SCOTUS 1907-03-25 p. 715
216 U. S. 616 216 U. S. 616 p. 715