Carlisle v. South Dakota — 238 U.S. 609

Majority

p. 609

No. 249.

C. L. Carlisle, Plaintiff in Error, v. The State of South Dakota.

Syllabus

In error to the Supreme Court of the State of South Dakota. -

Submitted April 16, 1915.

Decided April 19, 1915.

Mr. Melvin Grigsby for the plaintiff in error. Mr. Chas. O. Bailey, Mr. Royal C. Johnson and Mr. John H. Voorhees for the defendant in error.

Dismissed for the want of jurisdiction upon the authority of Farrell v. O’Brien, 199 U. S. 89 , 100; Fay v. Crozer, 217 U. S. 455 ; Hendricks v. United States, 223 U. S. 178 , 184; see Dent v. West Virginia, 129 U. S. 114 ; Reetz v. Michigan, 188 U. S. 505 ; Watson v. Maryland, 218 U. S. 173 ; Collins v. Texas, 223 U. S. 288 .

Cases cited

Farrell v. O'Brien 199 U. S. 89 SCOTUS 1905-05-29 p. 609
Fay v. Crozer 217 U. S. 455 SCOTUS 1910-05-02 p. 609
Hendricks v. United States 223 U. S. 178 SCOTUS 1912-02-19 p. 609
Dent v. West Virginia 129 U. S. 114 SCOTUS 1889-01-14 p. 609
Reetz v. Michigan 188 U. S. 505 SCOTUS 1903-02-23 p. 609
Watson v. Maryland 218 U. S. 173 SCOTUS 1910-05-31 p. 609
Collins v. Texas 223 U. S. 288 SCOTUS 1912-02-19 p. 609