Majority
p. 537No. 46. Edmund Penfold et al., Executors, etc., et al. v. Eugene M. Travis, as Comptroller of the State of New York. Argued November 15, 1918. Decided November 18, 1918.
Syllabus
Error to the Surrogate’s Court, New York County, State of New York.Mr. William Mitchell for plaintiffs in error. Mr. John B. Gleason for defendant in error.
Dismissed for want of jurisdiction upon the authority of (1) Consolidated Turnpike Co. v. Norfolk &c. Ry. Co., 228 U. S. 596 ; Bilby v. Stewart, 246 U. S. 255 , 257; Municipal Securities Corporation v. Kansas City, 246 U. S. 63 , 69; Cuyahoga River Power Co. v. Northern Realty Co., 244 U. S. 300 . (2) Farrell v. O’Brien, 199 U. S. 89 ; Empire State-Idaho Mining Co. v. Hanley, 205 U. S. 225 ; Goodrich v. Ferris, 214 U. S. 71 ; Brolan v. United States, 236 U. S. 216 .
Cases cited
- Consolidated Turnpike Co. v. Norfolk & Ocean View Railway Co. 228 U. S. 596 p. 537
- Bilby v. Stewart 246 U. S. 255 p. 537
- Municipal Securities Corp. v. Kansas City 246 U. S. 63 p. 537
- Cuyahoga River Power Co. v. Northern Realty Co. 244 U. S. 300 p. 537
- Farrell v. O'Brien 199 U. S. 89 p. 537
- Empire State-Idaho Mining & Developing Co. v. Hanley 205 U. S. 225 p. 537
- Goodrich v. Ferris 214 U. S. 71 p. 537
- Brolan v. United States 236 U. S. 216 p. 537