Majority
p. 542No. 60. Herbert M. Sears v. Inhabitants of the Town of Nahant, etc. Argued December 16, 1918. Decided December 23, 1918.
Syllabus
Error to the Superior Court of the, State of Massachusetts.Dismissed
p. 543
for want of jurisdiction upon the authority of (1) McCain v. Des Moines, 174 U. S. 168 , 181; Western Union Telegraph Co. v. Ann Arbor R. R. Co., 178 U. S. 239 , 243; Hull v. Burr, 234 U. S. 712 , 720; Norton v. Whiteside, 239 U. S. 144 , 147. (2) Farrell v. O’Brien, 199 U. S. 89 , 100; Empire State-Idaho Mining Co. v. Hanley, 205 U. S. 225 , 232; Goodrich v. Ferris, 214 U. S. 71 , 79; Brolan v. United States, 236 U. S. 216 . (3) Consolidated Turnpike Co. v. Norfolk &c. Ry. Co., 228 U. S. 596 , 599; Cuyahoga River Power Co. v. Northern Realty Co., 244 U. S. 300 , 304; Bilby v. Stewart, 246 U. S. 255 , 257.
Mr. Burton E. Eames for plaintiff in error. Mr. Robert G. Dodge, with whom Mr. Arthur D. Hill and Mr. Richard H. Wiswall were on the brief, for defendant in. error.
Cases cited
- McCain v. Des Moines 174 U. S. 168 p. 543
- Western Union Telegraph Co. v. Ann Arbor Railroad 178 U. S. 239 p. 543
- Hull v. Burr 234 U. S. 712 p. 543
- Norton v. Whiteside 239 U. S. 144 p. 543
- Farrell v. O'Brien 199 U. S. 89 p. 543
- Empire State-Idaho Mining & Developing Co. v. Hanley 205 U. S. 225 p. 543
- Goodrich v. Ferris 214 U. S. 71 p. 543
- Brolan v. United States 236 U. S. 216 p. 543
- Consolidated Turnpike Co. v. Norfolk & Ocean View Railway Co. 228 U. S. 596 p. 543
- Cuyahoga River Power Co. v. Northern Realty Co. 244 U. S. 300 p. 543
- Bilby v. Stewart 246 U. S. 255 p. 543