Majority
p. 537No. 69. Edward E. O’Brien et al. v. Public Service Commission of the First District of the State of New York, etc. Argued November 12, 1919. Decided November 17, 1919.
Syllabus
Error to the Supreme Court of the State of New York.Dismissed for want of jurisdiction upon the authority of: (i) California Powder Works v. Dams, 151 U. S. 389 , 393; Sayward v. Denny, 158 U. S. 180 , 183; Harding v. Illinois, 196 U. S. 78 , 86. (2) Thomas v. Iowa, 209 U. S. 258 , 263; Bowe v. Scott, 233 U. S. 658 , 664; and see El Paso Sash & Door Co.. v. Carraway, 245 U. S. 643 . Mr. Robert H. Elder for plaintiffs in error. Mr. William P. Búrr and Mr. John F. O’Brien for defendant in error, submitted.
Cases cited
- California Powder Works v. Davis 151 U. S. 389 p. 537
- Sayward v. Denny 158 U. S. 180 p. 537
- Harding v. Illinois 196 U. S. 78 p. 537
- Thomas v. Iowa 209 U. S. 258 p. 537
- Bowe v. Scott 233 U. S. 658 p. 537
- El Paso Sash & Door Co. v. Carraway 245 U. S. 643 p. 537