Winston Bros. v. Stover — 299 U.S. 508

Majority

p. 508

No. 338.

Winston Brothers Co. v. Stover.

Jurisdictional statement distributed September 10, 1936.

Decided October 12, 1936.

Messrs. Robert H. Evans, William G. McLaren, J. Speed Smith, and Norman M. Littell for appellant.

Mr. Samuel B. Bassett for appellee.

The motion of the appellee to dismiss the appeal herein is granted, and the appeal is dismissed (1) for the want of a substantial federal question (Atkin v. Kansas, 191 U. S. 207 , 223, 224; Heim v. McCall, 239 U. S. 175 , 191-193; Caldwell v. Louisiana, 282 U. S. 801 ; Gianatasio v. Kaplan, 284 U. S. 595 ); (2) for the reason that the judgment sought here to be reviewed is based upon a non-federal ground adequate to support it. Pierce v. Somerset Railway, 171 U. S. 641 , 648; Leonard v. Vicksburg R. Co., 198 U. S. 416 , 422, 423; McCoy v. Shaw, 277 U. S. 302 , 303. The motion of the appellee to allow damages is granted, and it is ordered that damages of one thousand dollars, payable to appellee, be taxed against appellant. Slaker v. O’Connor, 278 U. S. 188 ; Roe v. Kansas, 278 U. S. 191 ; Mississippi Central R. Co. v. Aultman, 296 U. S. 537 .

Atkin v. Kansas 191 U. S. 207 SCOTUS 1903-11-30 at 224 p. 508
Heim v. McCall 239 U. S. 175 SCOTUS 1915-11-29 p. 508
282 U. S. 801 282 U. S. 801 p. 508
Cousins v. Sovereign Camp 284 U. S. 595 SCOTUS 1932-01-18 p. 508
Pierce v. Somerset Railway 171 U. S. 641 SCOTUS 1898-10-31 p. 508
Leonard v. Vicksburg, Shreveport & Pacific Railroad 198 U. S. 416 SCOTUS 1905-05-29 at 423 p. 508
McCoy v. Shaw 277 U. S. 302 SCOTUS 1928-05-21 p. 508
Slaker v. O'Connor 278 U. S. 188 SCOTUS 1929-01-02 p. 508
Roe v. Kansas ex rel. Smith 278 U. S. 191 SCOTUS 1929-01-02 p. 508
296 U. S. 537 296 U. S. 537 p. 508