Hyperlawhypertext legal database Messina v. Commissioner 562 U.S. 1171

← Cases

Messina v. Commissioner

562 U.S. 1171 Court SCOTUS Decision date 2011-01-10 Docket No. 09-1463; No. 09-10496; No. 09-10655; No. 09-10690; No. 09-10705; No. 09-10709; No. 09-10763; No. 09-10764; No. 09-10784; No. 09-10818; No. 09-10946; No. 09-11037; No. 09-11044; No. 09-11070; No. 09-11081; No. 09-11108; No. 09-11248; No. 09-11545; No. 09-11559; No. 10-280; No. 10-299; No. 10-338; No. 10-381; No. 10-393; No. 10-5028; No. 10-5161; No. 10-5184; No. 10-5275; No. 10-5304; No. 10-5380; No. 10-5474; No. 10-5485; No. 10-5501; No. 10-5514; No. 10-5518; No. 10-5519; No. 10-5568; No. 10-5589; No. 10-5597; No. 10-5630; No. 10-5668; No. 10-5681; No. 10-5701; No. 10-5729; No. 10-5814; No. 10-5823; No. 10-5824; No. 10-5890; No. 10-5899; No. 10-5949; No. 10-5960; No. 10-5963; No. 10-5972; No. 10-5977; No. 10-6012; No. 10-6019; No. 10-6055; No. 10-6057; No. 10-6101; No. 10-6120; No. 10-6122; No. 10-6168; No. 10-6198; No. 10-6276; No. 10-6293; No. 10-6310; No. 10-6359; No. 10-6369; No. 10-6393; No. 10-6419; No. 10-6452; No. 10-6461; No. 10-6466; No. 10-6478; No. 10-6483; No. 10-6501; No. 10-6516; No. 10-6520; No. 10-6641; No. 10-6711; No. 10-6860 English

Delivered by Majority

Contents

Majority

p. 1171
No. 09-1463.
No. 09-10496.
No. 09-10655.
No. 09-10690.
No. 09-10705.
No. 09-10709.
No. 09-10763.
No. 09-10764.
No. 09-10784.
No. 09-10818.
No. 09-10946.
No. 09-11037.
No. 09-11044.
No. 09-11070.
No. 09-11081.
No. 09-11108.
No. 09-11248.
No. 09-11545.
No. 09-11559.
Messina v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue, Meng v. Mecklenburg County Department of Social Services, Decker v. Dunbar et al., Booker v. Johnson, Director, Virginia Department of Corrections, Shaarbay v. Florida, Mason v. Cassady et al., Evans v. Eldridge et al., Davis v. Thaler, Director, Texas Department of Criminal Justice, Correctional Institutions Division, Grover v. Thaler, Director, Texas Department of Criminal Justice, Correctional Institutions Division, Fox v. Upton, Warden, et al., Silverman v. Hudson, Warden, Brothers v. Thaler, Director, Texas Department of Criminal Justice, Correctional Institutions Division, Xiao Qing Liu v. Richline Group et al., Gillard v. Michalakos et al., Blakeney v. Mississippi, Williams v. Thaler, Director, Texas Department of Criminal Justice, Correctional Institutions Division, Benjamin v. Shepherd et al., Postell v. Bank of Central Florida et al., Postell v. Bank of Central Florida et al.,

ante, p. 835;

ante, p. 845;

ante, p. 848;

ante, p. 849;

ante, p. 850;

ante, p. 851;

ante, p. 852;

ante, p. 853;

ante, p. 856;

ante, p. 860;

ante, p. 861;

ante, p. 862;

ante, p. 869;

ante, p. 887;

ante, p. 888;

p. 1172
Ghazibayat v. SBC Advanced Solutions, Inc., Yumin Zhao v. Lone Star Engine Installation Center, Inc., Tricome v. eBay Inc., Vance v. Illinois, Baird v. Burlington Northern & Santa Fe Railway Co. et al., Walsh v. Quinn et al., Merritt v. McNeil, Secretary, Florida Department of Corrections, et al., Roberts v. McCulloch, John R. G. v. Catholic Charities of Southern Nevada, Cox v. Florida, Blood v. United States, Corbin v. Wheeler, Warden, Meredith v. Florida, McNeil v. DiGuglielmo, Superintendent, State Correctional Institution at Graterford, Dillehay, aka Smith v. Astrue, Commissioner of Social Security, Kangere v. Davenport, Kriz v. 12th Judicial District Board of Mental Health of Box Butte County et al., Salter v. United States, Owens v. Marshall, Warden, Benjamin v. Reid et al., Rogers v. Thaler, Director, Texas Department of Criminal Justice, Correctional Institutions Division, Stafford v. Ammons et al., Reid v. Swift Transportation Co., Inc., Karawi v. United States, Nakagawa v. Colorado, Hung Ha v. Richman et al., Hubbard v. Detroit Public Schools, Taylor v. Yates, Warden,

No. 10-280.

No. 10-299.

No. 10-338.

No. 10-381.

No. 10-393.

No. 10-5028.

No. 10-5161.

No. 10-5184.

No. 10-5275.

No. 10-5304.

No. 10-5380.

No. 10-5474.

No. 10-5485.

No. 10-5501.

No. 10-5514.

No. 10-5518.

No. 10-5519.

No. 10-5568.

No. 10-5589.

No. 10-5597.

No. 10-5630.

No. 10-5668.

No. 10-5681.

No. 10-5701.

No. 10-5729.

No. 10-5814.

No. 10-5823.

No. 10-5824.

ante, p. 1004;

ante, p. 1005;

ante, p. 1030;

ante, p. 899;

ante, p. 907;

ante, p. 908;

ante, p. 912;

ante, p. 914;

ante, p. 918;

ante, p. 924;

ante, p. 925;

ante, p. 926;

ante, p. 929;

ante, p. 930;

ante, p. 932;

ante, p. 965;

ante, p. 934;

ante, p. 935;

ante, p. 936;

ante, p. 967;

ante, p. 968;

p. 1173
Moore v. Tennis, Superintendent, State Correctional Institution at Rockview, et al., McCray v. Wal-Mart Stores, Inc., et al., Spisak v. Nevada, Campanile v. Nicolella, Executor of the Estate of Renzi, Deceased, Bustos Anaya v. Sisto, Warden, Blackmer v. Sweat et al., Stapley v. Mississippi Bar et al., Harris v. Progressive Northern Insurance Co. et al., Martin v. Johnson, Director, Virginia Department of Corrections, Arnaiz v. United States, Miller v. Kolender et al., In re Sancho, Winnett v. Saline County Jail et al., Stout v. Hobbs, Warden, Stinski v. Georgia, Leiser v. Thurmer, Warden, McClellan v. Hobbs, Director, Arkansas Department of Correction, McCaslin v. Birmingham Museum of Art et al., Webb v. Kern, Judge, Circuit Court of South Dakota, Pennington County, et al., Wynter v. New York, In re Sanders, Jones v. City of North Platte, Nebraska, et al., Blade v. United States, Metcalf v. United States, Rainey v. United States, Holmes v. United States, Taylor v. New Jersey et al., Garvins v. Burnett et al., In re Dominguez, Kendricks v. Barrow, Warden,

No. 10-5890.

No. 10-5899.

No. 10-5949.

No. 10-5960.

No. 10-5963.

No. 10-5972.

No. 10-5977.

No. 10-6012.

No. 10-6019.

No. 10-6055.

No. 10-6057.

No. 10-6101.

No. 10-6120.

No. 10-6122.

No. 10-6168.

No. 10-6198.

No. 10-6276.

No. 10-6293.

No. 10-6310.

No. 10-6359.

No. 10-6369.

No. 10-6393.

No. 10-6419.

No. 10-6452.

No. 10-6461.

No. 10-6466.

No. 10-6478.

No. 10-6483.

No. 10-6501.

No. 10-6516.

ante, p. 940;

ante, p. 969;

ante, p. 984;

ante, p. 985;

ante, p. 1007;

ante, p. 944;

ante, p. 1008;

ante, p. 1001;

ante, p. 986;

ante, p. 1009;

ante, p. 1011;

ante, p. 971;

ante, p. 987;

ante, p. 1031;

ante, p. 1032;

ante, p. 1043;

ante, p. 1047;

ante, p. 988;

ante, p. 989;

ante, p. 1048;

ante, p. 1015;

p. 1174
Brim, aka Horne v. Zavares, Executive Director, Colorado Department of Corrections, et al., Martinez v. United States, Torres v. United States, Birtha v. United States,

No. 10-6520.

No. 10-6641.

No. 10-6711.

No. 10-6860.

ante, p. 1015;

ante, p. 1017;

ante, p. 1018; and

ante, p. 1035. Petitions for rehearing denied.